Natural Human Freedoms as the Basis of Legal Regulation

The article provides a new approach to understanding natural human rights. The author reviews the existing concepts of natural law: ancient philosophers, religious figures of the Middle Ages and the New Age, philosophers of the Enlightenment, I. Kant, the views of modern lawyers, reflected in fundamental international documents and national constitutions. It is concluded that the existing concepts are based on assumptions, many of their provisions are outdated and often contradict each other, and the content of the natural human rights themselves is not disclosed. The author is critical of the opinion that natural law is morality or divine law. Instead, it is proposed to build a concept based on the biological characteristics of the human body. To substantiate the new approach, the author applies the method of R. Descartes — denial until the very denial becomes absurd. Thanks to this method, an objective basis was found — «a person exists while he lives», from which further reasoning is conducted. The article provides a logically justified and integral system of natural human rights, which the author calls “human natural freedoms”. These include natural freedoms: life, consumption, labor, worldview, knowledge and selfdefense. The author proves that they are inalienable, absolute, independent in use and permanent. The article also shows how the objectively existing system of natural human freedoms interacts with positive law. The author notes that the role of such a “bundle” is played by the principles of regulation, which include: universality, equality and fairness. In conclusion, a conclusion is made about the theoretical and practical significance of the presented concept.

1. Aquinas, F. The Sum of Theology. Volume VIII. Question 57. About law. Section 2 [Summa teologii. Tom VIII. Vopros 57. O prave. Razdel 2] [Electronic resource]. URL: https://azbyka.ru/otechnik/konfessii/summa-teologii-tom-8/11 (date of access: 02/01/2023).

2. Aristotle. Ethics to Nicomachus [Jetika k Nikomahu]. Ethics [Jetika] / Aristotle; per. E. Radlova. M.: Publishing house AST, 2021. P. 3–294.

3. Aronson, D. O. Kant: Transcendental Substantiation of the Principles of Law: The PhD Thesis [Kant: transcendental’noe obosnovanie principov prava: dis. kand. filos. nauk]. M., 2015. 157 p.

4. Hobbes, T. Leviathan [Leviafan]. M.: Mysl, 2001. 478 p.

5. Descartes, R. The Origins of Philosophy. Reasoning about the Method [Pervonachala filosofii. Rassuzhdenija o metode] / Descartes R.; per. from fr. G. Slyusareva, S. Sheinman-Topshtein. M.: AST Publishing House, 2020. P. 229–415.

6. Diderot, D. Natural Freedom. Philosophy in the Encyclopedia of Diderot and D’Alembert [Estestvennaja svoboda. Filosofija v Jenciklopedii Didro i Dalambera] / Institute of Philosophy. M.: Nauka, 1994. P. 219–220.

7. Diderot, D. Law (Natural, Moral, Divine, Human). Philosophy in the Encyclopedia of Diderot and D’Alembert [Zakon (estestvennyj, moral’nyj, bozhij, chelovecheskij). [Filosofija v Jenciklopedii Didro i Dalambera] / Institute of Philosophy. M.: Nauka, 1994. P. 226–228.

8. Kozlihin, I. Yu., Timoshina, E. V. History of Political and Legal Doctrines. Course of lectures: textbook [Istorija politicheskih i pravovyh uchenij. Kurs lekcij: uchebnoe posobie]. 2nd ed., revised. and additional M.: Prospekt, 2016. 288 p.

9. Kropotkin, P. A. Ethics / Ethics: Selected Works [Jetika. Jetika: Izbrannye Trudy]. M.: Politizdat, 1991. P. 22–258.

10. Locke, J. Two Treatises on Government [Dva traktata o pravlenii] / ed., M.: Canon +, ROOI “Rehabilitation”, 2009. P. 57–385. (Transl. from English).

11. Montesquieu, Sh. L. On the Spirit of Laws [O duhe zakonov]. Transl. by A. Gornfeld; M.: RIPOL classic, 2019. 690 p. (Transl. from French).

12. Pivovarov, Yu. S. Natural Law and Social Ethics in the XX Century Introductory Remarks (review) [Estestvennoe pravo i social’naja jetika v XX stoletii: vvodnye zamechanija (obzor)]. Law of the XX century: Ideas and values [Pravo HH veka: Idei i cennosti]. 2001. No. 2001. P. 137–177.

13. Plato. Gorgias. Collected works in 4 volumes: T. I [Gorgij. Sobranie sochinenij v 4 t.: T. I] / Plato; total ed. A. F. Loseva and others M.: Mysl, 1990. P. 477–574.

14. Radishchev, A. N. Experience on Legislation. Complete Collection of Works. T. 3 [Opyt o zakonodatel’stve. Polnoe sobranie sochinenij. T. 3]. M., Leningrad: Publishing House of the Academy of Sciences of the USSR, 1952. P. 5–27.

15. Rousseau, J.-J. On the Social Contract, or the Principles of Political Law. On the Social Contract. Treatises [Ob obshhestvennom dogovore, ili principy politicheskogo prava. Ob obshhestvennom dogovore. Traktaty] / transl. by A. D. Khayutin, V. S. Alekseev-Popov. M.: KANON-press, Kuchkovo pole, 1998. P. 195–322. (Transl. from French.)

16. Rousseau, J.-J. Reasoning About the Origin and Foundations of Inequality Between People. On the social contract. Treatises [Rassuzhdenija o proishozhdenii i osnovanijah neravenstva mezhdu ljud’mi. Ob obshhestvennom dogovore. Traktaty] / transl. by A. D. Khayutin. M.: KANON-press, Kuchkovo pole, 1998. P. 51–150. (Transl. from French.)

17. Frolova, E. A. Philosophy of Law in Russia: Neo-Kantianism (second half of the 19th — first half of the 20th century) : monograph [Filosofija prava v Rossii: neokantianstvo (vtoraja polovina XIX — pervaja polovina XX veka) : monografija]. M.: Prospekt, 2019. 464 p.